Thursday, 10 December 2009

One need not wait till the end of trial to say Amway's business model is illegal

Young people, these days, are very anxious to become rich as early as possible to enjoy life while they are still young. It could be understood. To achieve that goal, they could choose a lawful business or study hard to become a professional. Those who can't do these both naturally become anti-social elements. That is what happened with these Amway apologists.
Youngman Trivedi raised a point. He said, "besides this ur point against amway regarding money circulation scheme its like considering court giving final verdict regarding murder and accusing of murder both as same."
It is true no one is guilty unless it is proved otherwise in the court of law.
Addressing this aspect, the Andhra Pradesh High Court refused to agree to it. Just read the following.
"Sri B Adinarayana (Counsel for Amway India) contended that even assuming that the police are satisfied that the petitioners (Amway India) are indulging in money circulation scheme, they cannot interfere with the business of the petitioner till the criminal court after a full fledged trial holds the petitioners guilty of the offence alleged against them. We have carefully considered this submission of the learned counsel. It is a well settled principle of criminal jurisprudence that no person shall presumed to be guilty until his guilt is proved, but we are unable to accept the broad submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioners (Amway India) that till the conclusion of the criminal case the police have no power to interfere with the business activities of the petitioners. Section 7 of Act (Prize Chits & Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act, 1978) empowers the police officer not below the rank of an officer in charge of a police station to that effect."
So the Amway India's business model is a money circulation scheme and is illegal.


Tex said...

Guilty until proven innocent. Interesting view....NOT!

dtytrivedi said...

its shyam who till now has propogated that its 2-5 yrs get rich quick scheme.....

u cannot say its illegal until its proved that it is illegal. if it was illegal then it would have been the frontpage news.

So don't conclude until it is concluded. by writing this post its more crystal clear that its you who have been misleading the people.

dtytrivedi said...

its very strange that if people by from retail shop its fine but if they by from a place where they get returns from their expense it becomes scheme!!!

besides this shyam and legal scan have been continously talking about exorbitant price but the reality is that don't know more than a toothpaste price, besides when I tell them how it is more effective they fail to accept their mistake.

they tell its one our gimmicks. I tell u one thing go and check by urself, take a toothpast of ur choice take a plastic bottle and then rub the paste about 50 times, and u will see the result but when u use this paste u will see the different result.

I have seen my uplines showing the same demo to dentist too. they too believe on the result. But this silly people won't believe until it is approved from andhra pradesh high court.

dtytrivedi said...

yeah u are write, one cannot wait for 50 yrs and still counting and wait that one day this model will be proved illegal it better to do the business with amway.

World is not as fool as u think, the legal system of the other developed countries are far more effective than us.

If amway is proved legal over there than why i would i should even suspect despite knowing that its model has been proved to be legal in several occasions even in those countries where are laws are less liberal and less flexible!!!

Its simply a matter of common sense. By tagging the business opportunity in a wrong as u are propagating does make it illegal.